*Continued*
thus in the supernatural, there is no law stating life cannot be created by non-life, or intelligence from non-intelligence. essentially you are throwing away the laws of the natural pertaining to the supernatural in one location and imposing them on it in another to come up with your perfect mental creation: God
The flaw in this is, in your own argument in the "square-circle" analogy where God existed outside the laws of the world he created and thus could make them as he wished. This brings up the fact that if there is a super-natural outside of our 'natural' then it is also outside of the reality we perceive, and thus not following the cause and effect line of events
Taking this further if we still assume there was a first cause, we then have to throw out the arbitrary laws by which you define it.
Shiladie's recent comments: