A neat idea, but integrity as a Superman fan means Brandon Routh/Jason Schwartzman = lose, -1. Nothing personal. It's well-done given the material, but the material is Routh.
As for those who find "Top 5" to be a misleading title: what if it were called "Random 5 Wins" or something like that that doesn't suggest an empirical rank?
Re: roq's idea for anonymous submissions: Say you could submit anonymously (to avoid fanvoting and revenge downvoting) and the site's author isn't revealed to a viewer until they submit their non-changeable vote. That way there might be unbiased voting and the author is recognized.
SevenCubed's recent comments: