first-of-two's favorites:

site average score creator added on
?Kirk Douglas Wants Sundaes! (4.44) syncan 2006-06-22
Superior.
first-of-two 2006-06-22
?Captain America Doesn't Surrender (4.24) Trenchgun 2006-07-05
heh.
first-of-two 2006-07-05
?Last Voyager 2 Transmission (4.42) mrgrim 2006-07-06
Best LOL site ever.
first-of-two 2006-07-06
?A tear for Scotty (bagpipes) (4.18) MelonSoda5000 2006-07-06
Scotty tribute
first-of-two 2006-07-06
?Having A Bad Day? (4.44) Blue525 2006-07-12
2 cute
first-of-two 2006-07-12
?YTBHND: You're the Bobblehead Now Dog! (4.17) Phrozinphish 2006-07-13
bobbleheads. HA!
first-of-two 2006-07-13
?The Un-Funny Truth About Westboro Baptist Chur... (4.20) RussianDog 2006-08-08
True. Damn those scum.
first-of-two 2006-08-08
?Jesus noooooo! (4.34) thegaypope 2006-08-10
First ytmnd to make me snort with laughter.
first-of-two 2006-08-10
?Alternate Endings to "Death and the Captain&... (4.22) Chichiri 2006-08-19
The many deaths of Jean-Luc Picard
first-of-two 2006-08-19
?Gmod Far Side Cartoons (4.53) Joehadenuf 2006-09-20
Far Side + Gmod = WIN.
first-of-two 2006-09-20
?BLINDTMND - Wonder Cat (4.12) AskAak 2006-09-23
That's really Stevie.
first-of-two 2006-09-23
?Pale Blue Dot (an atheist's view - tiny update) (4.09) Lave 2006-09-28
Pale Blue Dot - Flawless Victory.
first-of-two 2006-09-28
?Not So Secret Islamic Sean Connery (3.91) IanS3004 2006-10-19
Holy War!
first-of-two 2006-10-19
?Color ME YTMND (4.70) nutnics 2006-10-19
Good.
first-of-two 2006-10-19
?We Didn't Start This Website! (4.77) NeoMatrixClt 2007-02-10
Only 5'ed because I couldn't 6 it.
first-of-two 2007-02-10
?(nsfw) Indiana Jones and The Uncontrollable Urges... (4.20) kenporules 2007-03-24
Funniest Indy ever!
first-of-two 2007-03-24
?The Size Of Our World - Special Edition (4.58) surfanddestroy 2007-04-02
new size of our world
first-of-two 2007-04-02
?Stephanie will fuck you up. (4.62) VinzClortho 2007-04-21
Stephanie kills.
first-of-two 2007-04-21
?Tron is a Firestarter (4.28) MrSinistar 2007-09-04
You mess with Tron, you get a Frisbee up the butt.
first-of-two 2007-09-04
?The Future of our World (4.70) fwywarrior 2007-09-15
Future of world. Good.
first-of-two 2007-09-15
?(nsfw) Holy shi* it's a Dinosaur! WTF? (juras... (4.67) ALMusic 2007-12-06
Fucking Dinosaurs!
first-of-two 2007-12-06
?ReBoot the U.S.A. (3.77) GaryGnu 2009-07-08
?NATIONAL LAMPOON’S: WHITE HOUSE (4.09) Rellikmit 2009-08-08
?You will not remember this ytmnd (4.55) N199APLZ 2009-08-08